Madison Police Chiefs
- Fred Mohr, 1856-1857 (City Marshal)
- Andrew Bishop, 1857-1858, 1862-1863,1872-1875, 1877-1879, 1881
- John Shealey, 1859, 1867, 1870
- Fred S. Van Bergen, 1860-1861
- John B. Hyland, 1864
- Ira W. Bird, 1865
- Ben F. Larkin, 1866
- William Hickey, 1867 (Failed to qualify)
- Joshua W. Tolford, 1868
- Theodore C. Botsford, 1869
- Charles C. Hammer, 1871
- Frank Dorn, 1876
- Benjamin D. Miner, 1880 (Jan. - Aug.)
- John L. Lewis, 1880, 1882-1885
- Edward Lyons, 1886
- John E. Adamson, 1887-1894 (Big Jack)
- Charles W. Heyl, 1895 (Later became fire chief)
- E.S. Parkison, 1896
- Henry C. Baker, 1897-1907
- Thomas Shayghnessy, 1907-1925
- Frank Trostle, 1925-1930
- Harry Davenport, 1930 (May - December)
- William H. McCormick, 1931-1948
- Bruce Weatherly, 1949-1959 – Fired for Improprieties
- Wilbur H. Emry, 1959-1972
- David C. Couper, 1973-1993 (Longest tenure as Madison Police Chief)
- Richard K. Williams, 1993-2004
- Noble Wray 2004-